The case for the dedicated e-reader: When it’s time to go off the grid
by Steve O'Hear
on September 10, 2010

The case for the dedicated e-readerWith the advent of the iPad and the plethora of cheaper Android tablets that are due to flood the market over the coming months, there’s an increasingly popular theory in the tech industry: the days of the dedicated e-reader are numbered.

Last week we published the latest forecasts from Informa Telecoms & Media analysts that said as much. Sales of ‘smartbooks’ (a loosely defined term) are expected to grow from 3.65 million in 2010 to nearly 50 million in 2014, or over 50% of all embedded device sales. The losers will be dedicated e-readers, such as the Amazon Kindle or Sony Reader, and the winners, multifunctional portable devices like the iPad and Samsung Galaxy Tab.

The reasoning – and it’s convincing – is that e-book content is now available on most multifunctional devices like mobiles and tablets that work well enough as book readers, while having other functions.

Or as our very own Paul Carr says: When faced with a choice of carrying a multifunctional tablet like the iPad or a dedicated e-reader, users will choose the former.

In fact, he goes further. Not only will the iPad and its ilk kill devices like the Kindle but it’s a nail in the coffin of (long form) reading too. The iPad has far too many tricks up its sleeve, each competing for our attention.

However, I have a confession to make: I’m now a total Kindle convert.

Yes, I know. It’s a laughable notion to anybody that knows me well and judging by the number of unread books – mostly Christmas presents from friends who should know better – that occupy shelf space and the spare cupboard in my house. But I can’t get enough of the Kindle.

Why?

It’s the only gadget that encourages me – no, forces me – to go off the grid and get away from, as Mike Butcher puts it, the “background hum” of being always-connected. In fact, it’s for exactly the reasons that Carr states, that the dedicated e-reader can be seen as the anti-iPad. And that might well be its long-term appeal.

The Kindle has WiFi and, optionally, 3G but thankfully its built-in web browser – marked “experimental” – is crap. There’s also no Twitter, no email, no push notifications. No background hum.

Throw in the technical merits of a dedicated e-reader: The e-Ink screen that eliminates eye strain associated with back-lit LCD screens and means that it can comfortably be read in direct sun light, the (up to) month-long battery life, the relatively light weight of the device — and, for many, the case becomes even more compelling.

But, mostly, I’m attracted to the Kindle because – shocking as it may seem to TechCrunch readers – it’s necessary (no, healthy) to go off the grid sometimes. If only to get away from work.

On that note, the first book that I’m reading on my newly purchased Kindle is Paul Carr’s “Bringing Nothing To The Party – True Confessions of a New Media Whore“. A book that is, largely, about Internet startup life in London.

Yeah, I know…

Advertisement
  • http://LBJ.org.uk Laura James

    If I plan to concentrate on reading for a while, I just turn my Android phone to airplane mode, and pull up an ebook reader app – Kindle or something else.

    That’s not to say I won’t be tempted by the screensize and battery life of an actual Kindle…

  • Katie

    Another reason I will never give up my Kindle for a shiny tablet?

    Shininess.

    Reading on a luminescent screen hurts. You have to give your eyes breaks every now and then. With a good book, I don’t want to tear my eyes away.

  • http://techtoom.com vikash

    For me hard printed books are still the best. It dont consume battery, never hang, fully bio degradable and looks awesome in your bookshelf.

    Regards
    Vikash
    TechToom.com

  • Matt

    I’m the same; while the iPad is techy-goodness, there’s just something about the non-distractedness of the Kindle that I don’t see myself moving away from.

  • http://www.pieto.com Piet

    There is way to turn off the background hum that is a lot cheaper, a lot more fun and a lot healthier than either Kindles or iPads. Go to the library. Chat up the librarian. Browse the books, select a few. Chat up the librarian. Go home. Pack a picnic basket. Find a shady tree. Enjoy your books.

  • Steve O’Hear

    That sounds like a lot of effort!

  • http://ziweb.tumblr.com ziweb

    Yeah, I’ve been arguing about this with my iPad friends. Kindle is definitely better for longer, deep reading. It’s easier on the eyes and let’s you concentrate. The question is, how many people want read like that?

  • http://www.techmindonline.com techmindonline

    …”small enough to fit in your pocket and not small enough to fit in your pocket” + the three major weekpoints for AIO vs. Dedicated Devices: http://bit.ly/cyepOK

  • http://doculinux.wordpress.com/2010/09/10/seguimos-hablando-de-web-semantica/ Seguimos hablando de Web Semántica « Doculinux

    [...] el contenido de una página web en un mapa de entidades a partir de su URL. Pongamos por ejemplo esta página en Techcrunch que se puede visualizar así. Es evidente que las redes sociales han supuesto una segunda [...]

  • http://fewmorecents.com Chirag

    Long live iPad!

  • http://www.wordgym.com MadaboutDana

    I’m looking forward to getting my paws on a Kindle. I think the iPad is amazing, but the battery life, light weight and sheer convenience of a Kindle are all very attractive. And I speak as somebody who already reads lots of eBooks on my iPhone!

    Two amusing considerations attract me in particular: first, I won’t worry about damaging a Kindle anything like as much as I would worry about an iPad. And second, I won’t have to p*ss about with iTunes to load anything worth reading onto the Kindle (although I have to say that Stanza on the iPhone is pretty d*mn cool). But for loading up business-related PDFs etc., gimme a Kindle every time…

  • http://librarytwopointzero.blogspot.com les

    I’m with Vikash on this one. E-reader’s are all well and good, but glare, battery life etc means that kindle’s,ipads and sony readers still have a long way to go to over take from a printed version.
    Also, the problem with ebooks i PERSONALLY find, is that a book shelf often tell you what the person is like (for example I leave if Margaret Thatcher’s biography is there). Call me nosey (and a labourite).
    I can see the advantage for some users (lack of room, disabled users needing a lighter device etc), but when I was a kid, I wanted to grow up and read books in front of a fire. I’ll have cocoa with it to……

  • Happy KillMore

    You know what you’re leaving out of the equation? How much does an iPad weigh? How much does a Kindle weigh? I got my wife a Kindle for Mothers’ Day and she reads from it in bed pretty much every day. She even told me not to get the big one, not because of the price difference (which was enough to convince me) but because of the weight difference.

    After all, not everyone puts their book on a table for reading.

  • Jay

    Just got the new Kindle in this week and for long form reading, the eInk screen is amazing. I thought there was a sticker on the screen showing basic setup when I opened the box, and quickly realized that was not a sticker but the screen itself. Very cool and very easy on the eyes. Was looking forward to an Android tablet, but now with a laptop and a Kindle, I am beginning to see less and less of a reason…

  • http://www.mayaparadise.com Phil L

    I wonder if some of the folks who argue that pads will kill ereaders either have never used an ereader, or are not into reading books and have not experienced becoming totally absorbed in a book.

    I’m in the camp that argues that the two products are completely different. The fact that a pad can imitate the function of an ereader (albeit with a poor display for reading purposes) is not relevant. I’m curious how this market will shake out and where this argument will be five years from now.

  • Albin

    I’m very interested in the latest Kindle, but do want the browser to work well enough to give access to DropBox, where I keep useful PDF documents in sync across devices. One hears very little about that browser in reviews, and I’d be interested in what it will and won’t do – don’t care if it’s elegant.

  • fmcfm

    Someday the two devices will be combined by using a Mirasol screen of something like it. That is, a screen that has low glare and uses reflective light light and low power requirements like the Kindle, but in color as well as BW, and with movie enabling refresh rates, like the iPad.

    That day may come in 2011, as Qualcomm has just announced the introduction of just such a device for the coming year.

  • Billreyn

    But there are displays that allow you to turn off the backlight. So you don’t have eyestrain.

  • lsbf

    I sold my iPad in favor of a Kindle. The Kindle is simple; it works great for reading — good contrast, doesn’t blink at you. Buying an iPad is like paying to get into a party with a cash bar.

    About 2 weeks after I got an iPad, Apple announced the iTunes agreement has changed, and I must accept lengthy, non-negotiable terms (written in legalese, which I do not speak). Without agreeing to the new terms, I could not use the iTunes store; could not update apps or purchase new ones. I did not want to be at the mercy of Apple’s whims, and did not want to pirate apps, so sold the iPad on CL, after a failed attempt at a negotiation with Apple. I wanted to continue under the “old” agreement or get a refund; they just say “no way.” Might is right! I’m interested to see what the Android tablets will offer, but think I’ll likely prefer my lightweight, high contrast Kindle.

  • http://abhiroopbasu.com abhiroopb

    I thought I would test the browser for you. I just got the Kindle yesterday and I am loving it!

    The browser is crap ONLY because of the way e-ink works. Basically, all it does is refreshes the screen every time the content changes.

    Imagine having a sheet of blank paper and drawing something on it. E-ink works a lot like that. Each new page is a new sheet of paper with drawings. So, every minute change requires the entire page to be “re-drawn”. This means that all the behaviour is very “jerky”.

    Also you can use dropbox, but there did not appear to be any way of downloading stuff.

  • http://fraynelson.com Nelson Medina

    I couldn’t agree more with this post. It accurately portrays my own case.

    Having said that, the one concern should be whether reading, real reading, is just dying out among sizeable portions of humankind.

  • Steve O’Hear

    I hope the browser never improves.

  • Dee

    I’m seriously considering the new Kindle even though I already own an iPad. The e-ink technology makes text a joy to read on :)

  • http://www.mayaparadise.com Phil L

    It’s not just the backlight. It’s the geometry of the LCD, with the active elements quite some distance behind the front surface. With an eInk display it appears as though the text printed right on the surface and the difference in eyestrain is remarkable.

    Have you actually looked at an eInk display in person? Looking at a photo of Kindle or other ereader doesn’t do it.

  • Angel

    I am a person that sold my Kindle after buying an iPad on release day. I thought that reading on the iPad was just as good. Big mistake. Almost six months later, I am picking up my new Kindle from the post office today. Why?

    I read more when I am less distracted with connections to the internet, popups with facebook notifications, etc.. Plus I could never really get that comfortable reading a book in bed (which is where I do most of my reading) with the iPad. I never had that problem with the Kindle. I tried reading on my HTC Evo and finally experienced my eyes getting tired from the light.

    To me, the Kindle is worth the money even if you have other devices that can ALSO do ebooks. I am firmly in the camp of owning a device that’s main purpose is for reading.

  • Hagay

    You can never actually turn off the backlight. LCD Screens emit light out, which will cause major eyestrain while reading something as long as a book, not to mention trouble focusing your eyes for long.
    E-Ink screens on the other hand, reflect light, just as paper would. The best way to describe them would be to say they print tiny spots of grayscale on the screen as pixels, and not emit them as grayscale light wavelength.

  • Steve O’Hear

    Good choice, even if you learned the hard way :)

  • http://twitter.com/PaulJoslin PaulJoslin

    This is the exact reason I’m still thinking I’ll get a Kindle soon. I have so many books to read / I want to read and finding the time to take a book with me and sit down is hard. You can also guarantee that reading on a screen for ipad / laptop / monitor – I’ll get distracted and receive eye strain…

    the kindle is there, for you to go sit outside and read – without having to lug the books with you.

    You also avoid the awkwardness, from people around you looking at what you were reading (the books cover) and making comments / asking questions.

  • bilbothejust

    Ok, I’ll throw in my two cents. I have owned Kindle 1 and 2 and the iPad and I tried the Nook. I will say unequivocally that the iPad is the superior eReader hands down. If you read in bed just prop it up on the headboard or pillow if you don’t have a headboard. If you read at the table, I built a small wooden stand. I didn’t have any of the intrusive apps loaded to bug me so didn’t worry about being bugged. Turn the sound off if you don’t want to hear new email alerts.

    The final decision for me was based on two things. The iPad displays a full page of text and more closely resembles a real book. The Kindle and Nook are just too darned small (you can also see which page your on and how many pages are left in the chapter whereas the Kindle gives you some goofy location number that means nothing).

    Number two is page turning. The Kindle page forward and back are so clumsy and when you consider the 6″ page size the page turns required are much greater than on the iPad where page turns are a breeze.

    iPad FTW!

  • MikeSims

    I’ve finally ordered my kindle for the same reasons you listed. I want to read again like I did as a kid, and getting off the grid is a big part of that. As much as I like paper books, I read fairly quickly, so the tactile experience is fairly short lived. Besides, I’m engrossed in the story if it is a good one, the paper isn’t that important. And although books look nice on a shelf to say ‘Oh, I’m literate,’ they are also a major pain to move and store when space is a premium.

    I don’t care for Apple products, but I recognize the value of the iPad. There’s no way I could read a novel on it, though. Complimentary, but not direct competition IMHO.

    My ideal device is ipad/dx sized and color e-ink so that my larger full color cookbooks, artbooks, and reference could have a digital home. I wouldn’t mind a trade in program, either.

  • http://www.libraries.wright.edu/noshelfrequired/?p=1452 Articles of Interest

    [...] I'm Reading The case for the dedicated e-reader: When is it time to go off the gridInkling for iPad: eTextbook Reading Done RightNBC video: Checking out library e-booksThe Future Of [...]

  • Gixbr

    Do you expect a mp3 player to have a browser as well?
    No! Because it was meant for you to listen to mp3 !
    When are people going to understand Tablets are not Ereaders?! They have applications that you can read on, same does my PC.
    It’s just so silly to compare both. Also it’s so silly people complaining about the web browser on Ereaders. It was not made for this.

  • http://www.techcrunch.com michael arrington

    Sometimes when I want to get off the grid I open a book made out of paper.

  • Steve

    I have the kindle app on all my devices, I started with my iPhone 3g, then moved to my pc, then to my macbook, then to my iPad. Love the kindle app for the price of books and selection. I (read paper books too.) I would love to try the actual kindle. I know I have read quite a bit more lately because the ubiquity that the kindle app allows. Bravo. I will eventually spend some money, now not much money at all on the eReader. I would suspect that the eReader will go the way of many electronic devices because of the tablet’s new found popularity (as a result of pretty good execution). I don’t think the need to unplug will be enough to keep it alive. I would suspect some type of integration of the e ink and the LCD screen will show up sooner or later to officially kill the need for an eReader. Innovation will in fact kill this article or rather the debate the article takes up.

    To be honest it is the elimination of paper books one needs to fear, such as the article briefly touches on. There is something about holding a book in your hands and reading you just really can’t argue with. It would suck to see them go.

  • Angel

    And what if you don’t own a book that you want to read? You get in a car and drive to the bookstore to get it. I like the option of getting it right then and there, most times paying less, and getting into it immediately. Am I lazy? Maybe.

  • Angel

    I could never get comfortable in bed or even relaxing on the couch. I never had that problem with the Kindle and there’s no extra steps I need to take to not be distracted or stands I need to build with a Kindle. I pick it up and get straight to reading…comfortably and with no distractions.

    The iPad will still get used though…I really do like reading my Zinio magazines on it and it’s great for all types of other uses. I think it serves as a decent ereader for someone who doesn’t read that often.

  • Brian Johnson

    I’m with Piet on this one. The library can’t be beat on price, and some of those librarians are cute, definitely worth chatting up. Still something to be said for a real book – readable in almost any light, infinite battery life, and it doesn’t short out if you spill coffee on it.

  • SZ

    With the ever-decreasing attention span of the american society, the amount of reading one can achieve on an ipad before the screen causes eye strain is much larger then what the average american actually reads per day sadly. People dont spend continuous hours reading a book so therefore the average person doesnt see the benefits of an ebook like the Kindle compared to what an ipad can do. People who actually read books understand that the Kindle kills the ipad in all reading related categories, but thats only a small percentage of people. I’d say its like when Galileo said the world was world but thats overly dramatic on my part.

    To the person who said that if they want to get away from the world while reading by putting their android thing on airplane mode, that kinda sounds to me like if your addicted to crack and you try to resolve it by putting all of your crack in a box right infront of you. You know that as soon as you find something interesting in your book your gonna be like “OMG im gonna tweet this hilarious line from the book!”

    Finally, I want to say that there’s few pleasures in the world I enjoy as much finishing the last line of the last page of the book, you feel like you’ve truly accomplished something. The physical book will never disappear, mainly because we need hard-copies for reference and research etc., but I think the feeling I just described from reading a real book, and I know other have this feeling as well, is the cherry on top on why real books will never become extinct. But a device like the Kindle could truly advance our society. No longer will students have to spend 60 dollars on elementary textbooks and college students thousands of dollars on books. No longer will children have to carry home 1,000 pages worth of social studies and grammar and science books in their backpacks. No more public school pass-me-down books that are so incredibly defaced that it can no longer be read, but there is no money in the budget to buy new ones.

    Buy an ipad if you truly think you will read with it. I hope to buy a Kindle in the near future, if I could stop spending my money on pot

  • RickT

    Being a complete Apple convert years ago and a toy freak, so buying a Kindle almost went against my desire for more of more and get an iPad, but I absolutely love my new Kindle. As much as I have always traveled and carried books, again, the Kindle is a godsend. Being a dedicated reader, small size, fractional cost of an iPad and no monthly bills, it is my go-to device.

    Already have a Apple notebook and iPhone, I need more connectivity like a third eye. My vision of the future and how other new devices may effect me is as cloudy as my mood ring, sor for now, it’s Kindle, or nothing.

  • SZ

    lol, I wish I could edit my typos .

    @fmcfm and other people who want a dual screen like tablet that can go from bright LCD to a b&w e-ink type screen, thats exactly what the Notion ink Adam is

  • http://www.shutl.co.uk Tom Allason

    steve, you have me convinced. just placed my order… bezos thanks you.

  • Albin

    Amazon has announced they are providing an SDK for Kindle app development and I’d hope DropBox will consider making their own, as they have for other devices, incl the iPad. I can see how some users would like the limited functionality as an escape from connectivity, but in my case it would be a big enhancement.

  • Jon H

    The kindle is better for one-handed reading, say on a crowded train when you need one hand to hold on the strap. You don’t need a free hand to turn the pages.

  • Jon H

    “There is something about holding a book in your hands and reading you just really can’t argue with.”

    Sure, but not everything really merits that. It’s like photographs. In the film days you had to pay to get every single exposure printed, including the blurry ones, the ones with the lens cap left on, the ones with your thumb over the lens, the one where everyone blinked.

    Now with digital, we take far more pictures (I should think), but we only pay to print the special ones.

    I think books will be the same. Lots of books are ephemeral, linked to current events, or making predictions that don’t pan out. Nobody cherishes the old copies of Excel manuals, biographies of pop stars, or alarmist Y2K warnings that found their way onto their shelves.

    People will still have shelves with their favorite books. They’ll read books first as digital media, and those with special meaning will be purchased (again, perhaps) as a physical object, perhaps an edition with high production values for the binding.

  • Steve O’Hear

    Oh no. I hope you like it!

  • Isabel

    One of my favorite things about my Nook is that I have yet to pay for a single book–I just rent EPUB and PDF books from my library’s website. Of course, I don’t get the physical experience of going to the library, but given that our city library is enormous and impersonal, I’m ok with it!

  • Gallagher

    I just got the new Kindle and I love it. The eInk is amazing.

    There is a reason that the Kindle is the best selling product on Amazon, the most wished-for, most gifted, and has the most five star reviews of any product on Amazon.

    Amazon has a lot of products.

    The Kindle isnt going anywhere.

  • RP

    The new Kindle WiFi is amazing in its lightness, quickness, and simplicity. The iPad is great for multitasking and doing a little reading. The Kindle is great for serious reading.

    I don’t think the Kindle is going to convert non-readers to readers, but I do think that serious readers will end up loving the device in a way you can’t with a tablet.

  • Sean

    I have to admit that, while the responses to the article mention many good reasons to choose Kindle over iPad, I find ‘excessive connectivity’ on the part of the iPad to be pretty weak. Afterall, there is an on/off switch for that. And if you really don’t want always on connectivity then just get the wi-fi version and download/connect only when you want to. That also keeps you from dealing with those nasty contract issues.

    Overall, I have to go with the iPad on this one, since to me it is a true multi-media entertainment device (which is what I want). It allows me to:

    View my favorite magazines in color
    Read comics in color
    View PDF’s in color
    See cover art/book illustrations in color
    Play games
    Watch videos
    Get books from Amazon, B&N, and iTunes
    Use it as a photo viewer
    Oh, and did I mention its IN COLOR.

    How can you NOT want all those features!

    That said, admittedly the Kindle wins in the areas of cost, non-shininess, e-Ink, device weight, and battery life. Can’t argue there, but I’ll trade all of that for my multi-media features. Plus all of this will improve with time.

    One other question to mull over that the nostalgic printed book readers didn’t raise — which is better for the environment: cutting down trees to print loads of books or filling up landfills with used iPads? Or in other words, which is the more eco-friendly option? I’ll let others weigh in here.

  • http://www.pieto.com Piet

    The good things in life need some effort. Pass the port, please.

  • http://kindleworld.blogspot.com Andrys

    As with Google docs, you should be able to download ‘mobi’ or ‘prc’ files you drop there.

    Those are directly downloadable to the Kindle and that’s how 30,000 books are available at Proj Gutenberg that way for the Kindle as well as at places like feedbooks.com or mnybks.net or even the Internet Archive’s text-area downloads.

    That is, unless dropbox prevents it and I don’t imagine they do.

    Non-Amazon books in non-DRM’d Kindle format usually end in .mobi or .prc — there is an outfit that converts any of the million free Google docs from ePub to mobi format for free and you can download the converted copies directly to the Kindle with the web browser.

  • billreyn

    Yes, I own the original Kindle. To illustrate my point check out this video of the Notion Ink Adam. It uses Pixel Qi. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WxgRBC47SAo

  • billreyn

    Taken from pixelqi.com For our first product, we have developed of a new class of screen that embodies epaper with color and video. With the backlight on, this screen is color and looks and acts just like a standard LCD; with the backlight off, it becomes a highly reflective e-paper display with support for rapid update and video.

    Check out the link in my post above to see it in action.

  • Tim

    It just depends on what you tend to read mostly. Most books (paper books) don’t have much color in them. If you mainly read comic books, graphic novels, and magazines, then sure, the ipad would probably be a better choice. If you’re more of a traditional book reader, the Kindle is the better choice.

    Again, you’re talking about multi-media, the Kindle isn’t designed or marketed for people who want a multi-media experience. It’s for people who want to read books.

  • http://bestportablegenerators.net/blog/uncategorized/the-case-for-the-dedicated-e-reader-when-its-time-to-go-off-the-grid-steve-oheartechcrunch-europe.html The case for the dedicated e-reader: When it’s time to go off the grid (Steve O’Hear/TechCrunch Europe) | Best Portable Generators

    [...] O’Hear / TechCrunch Europe:The case for the dedicated e-reader: When it’s time to go off the grid  —  With the advent of the iPad and the plethora of cheaper Android tablets that [...]

  • billreyn

    The benefit of a tablet is that you don’t have to carry around several devices though. I don’t think the Ipad is the best for reading either. As I posted above devices using things like Pixel Qi screens will be much better for reading. Will they be as good as eink? I’ll wait until I’ve actually used one for awhile to make that decision. Based on what I’ve seen of it I am hopeful.

  • http://www.broadstuff.com alanp

    Heck if your chat up schtick goes well enough you can enjoy the Librarian too ;)

    I’m with Piet on this – deed trees rule.

    (Sent from my iPad :D )

  • Albin

    Thanks to both above. I’ve been using Gutenberg mobi books in my PC Kindle app with no problems: they have to be loaded into a special “My Kindle Content” folder to appear in the reader app and to be available for “whispersync”. Meanwhile DropBox has its own special My DropBox folder for its own sync functions, and never the twain shall meet.

    I haven’t used the DropBox website much since it syncs files directly to local drives. Going there, I see alternatives to open documents right in the browser using a PDF reader, or to download to the hard drive.

    If the Kindle device’s browser does either of these it’s good enough – I could read the DropBox PDFs on the Kindle.

  • http://www.gobbits.de/the-case-for-the-dedicated-e-reader-when-it%e2%80%99s-time-to-go-off-the-grid/2012 The case for the dedicated e-reader: When it’s time to go off the grid : gobbits

    [...] Weiter bei Techcrunch Europe [...]

  • http://clytie-stillaliveandcausingtrouble.blogspot.com/ Clytie Siddall

    Disabled reader here. I’ve been reading ebooks for quite a few years now, starting with Palm PDAs and then moving to iPhones. I can hold a PDA or an iPhone in one hand, and turn pages with a tap of my thumb, where I can’t hold a paper book (heavier load, continual muscle tension) or turn paper pages (a gross movement requiring fine motor control). I can’t read off a white background, and my vision varies, so I need to be able to set the background colour and font size/type.

    I have no difficulty reading for long periods on my iPhone. I am really hanging out for an iPad, which I can prop up on my lap, and will use for many different tasks (crosswords! :D ). I am unsure whether I can justify also buying an e-Ink device, although I am curious about any benefits of that screen type. Like others above, when I don’t want interruptions I simply turn them off (and I have no impulse whatever to interrupt my reading by “tweeting that great line in the book”). Reading is a distinct, refreshing, luxurious experience for me, which I won’t dilute with interruptions. Also, interruptions or distractions interfere with my limited concentration (so I also use Readability in my browser).

    I think improved screens will change this situation (again, as mentioned by other commenters). Colour e-ink screens and function-specific screens are coming onto the market. Meanwhile, the iPhone is small and light enough for me to hold while reading, and eReader or Stanza provide an excellent reading experience on it. I look forward to having this experience on the iPad.

  • richard brooks

    True about the book shelf, and I will certainly never be rid of real books, but the truth is I would never have space to keep all the books I want to own! I cannot count the number of volumes that have fallen apart from being read and re read, and then due to new purchases never replaced. For anyone who loves reading more than they love the media of books, a digital reader will have to be part of their world, hoping all the ‘birthday hints’ have been sucsessful and I will be the proud owner of a new kindle with wi fi at the end of September.

  • http://librarianbyday.net/2010/09/top-ten-links-week-37/ Top Ten Links Week 37 | Librarian by Day

    [...] its why I got a Kindle! RT @mlibrarianus: “The case for the dedicated e-reader: When it’s time to go off the grid“ This article from Steve O’Hear at Tech Crunch talks about choosing Kindle for an [...]

  • http://anthonynp.wordpress.com/2010/09/25/kindle-ebook-sources-other-than-amazon/ Kindle eBook sources other than Amazon « Just Chillin …

    [...] of the notable articles that kept me up into the wee hours of the night include: – The case for the dedicated e-reader: When it’s time to go off the grid | TechCrunch - The New Kindle: An Excellent E-reader, Period. | [...]

  • http://ireaderreview.com/2010/10/02/6-kindle-related-threads/ 6 Kindle related threads « Kindle Review – Kindle 3 Review, iPad Review

    [...] Kindle 3 has certain magical qualities that are seldom mentioned. An excellent article at TechCrunch goes into one of them – I can’t get enough of the [...]

  • http://eu.techcrunch.com/2010/10/12/hold-the-front-page-financial-times-on-ipad-does-a-cool-1m-in-ad-revenue/ Hold the front page: Financial Times on iPad does a cool £1m in ad revenue

    [...] on Amazon’s Kindle, which only launched properly in the UK as of August (see my thoughts here), so it could be that we see the FT’s subscriptions get a further [...]

  • http://avich.com/blog/2010/11/01/my-pathetically-lame-kindle/ My Pathetically Lame Kindle « Aviche >140

    [...] of 140 characters and 60 seconds videos, in a world of push email and Blackberries, being able to lean back and loose yourself in a book for 5 hours is a priceless [...]

  • http://eu.techcrunch.com/2011/03/14/kindle-comes-to-carphone-warehouse-best-buy-free-on-some-mobile-contracts/ Kindle comes to Carphone Warehouse, Best Buy – “free” on some mobile contracts

    [...] readers will know that I love my Kindle. And with news today that Amazon’s eReader will be stocked at Carphone Warehouse, the [...]

  • http://refurbishedflatscreentvstore.com/1692/the-case-for-the-dedicated-e-reader-when-its-time-to-go-off-the-grid-steve-oheartechcrunch-europe/ The case for the dedicated e-reader: When it’s time to go off the grid (Steve O’Hear/TechCrunch Europe) | Refurbished Flat Screen TV Store

    [...] O’Hear / TechCrunch Europe:T&#1211&#1077 case f&#959r t&#1211&#1077 dedicated e-reader: W&#1211&#1077&#1495 &#1110t’s tim…  —  W&#1110t&#1211 t&#1211&#1077 advent &#959f t&#1211&#1077 iPad [...]

  • Lead Generation Software

    Thank you for taking time to share this information with everyone.
    Lead
    Generation Software

blog comments powered by Disqus
Advertisement